Why the Straight One? - Chapter 19: Chapter 19

Book: Why the Straight One? Chapter 19 2025-09-22

You are reading Why the Straight One? , Chapter 19: Chapter 19. Read more chapters of Why the Straight One? .

"What the fuck?"
Of all the ways I have been woken up, being shoved off of him while he tried to scramble off the bed has got to be one of the most disorienting to date. In my half wakefulness, I held on to him tightly, but he continued to push me away.
"Stop pushing me." I whined, my eyes still closed tightly.
"Get off of me and I will." I rolled over reluctantly, and he immediately jumped out of bed.
"What the hell, Alex?"
You know that time of morning when you just don't want to have to think, or talk to anybody, or be awake? That's how I felt right then. I really wasn't in the mood to have a conversation about me sleeping on his chest.
"I'm talking to you. Answer me!"
You know, I'm not the type who takes that kind of talk laying down. So instead of answering him, I lifted one hand and lazily flipped him off.
"Wow, real mature, Alex." I could practically feel the anger rolling off of him in waves.
"I'll talk to you if you ask me nicely, and not before." He let out his breath in an angry sigh, and I waited for him to speak.
"Would you please turn around and explain what the hell was going on?"
"Sure! Why didn't you ask like that before?" I rolled over and met his angry glare with a smile.
"Enough of the smart answers! Just tell me why the hell I woke up with you laying on top of me!" He was literally cringing like that was the most horrible thing he could think of. I have to admit, that pissed me off.
"Why are you acting like this is such a big deal?"
"Because I woke up to find that you had totally taken advantage of—-"
"Oh believe me, I was not taking advantage of you!"
"Than what the hell was that?"
"That was me trying to wake you up from a nightmare that looked pretty terrifying, and when you fall back asleep you wouldn't let go of me!"
I hadn't realized that we were yelling until the silence that followed my last sentence. Most of the anger fell from Thomas' face, but I could tell his guard was up.
"What did I say?" The memory of the nightmare seemed to come back to him, and he seemed extremely anxious that I didn't know what he had dreamed.
"Nothing that I could understand. Then I guess your dream changed or something."
It changed when I whispered in your ear. I wanted to add, but I held my tongue.
"Why didn't you wake me up?"
"I tried!"
"Not very hard, obviously! I'd much rather you woke me up then took your opportunity come lay down on me while I couldn't do anything about it!"
An ugly silence fell between us. I was fuming at his arrogant tone and his choice of words. The way he made it sound, you'd think I was some desperate slut jumping on any chance I could to be near him.
He knew it was a low blow. I could see it on his face, and yet he didn't say anything else. He just stood here, looking like his normally attractive self, anger only adding to his beauty.
And something in me wanted to hit him right then and there.
"My mistake." My voice was harder then I expected it to sound. "Next time I'll just slap you until you wake up, instead of taking my 'opportunity to be near you' since you seem to think that that's what I was doing.
It also might interest you to know that you aren't as big of a deal as you think. When I wake up to someone crying out in the night, I don't care who that is, my first reaction is to try and comfort them. This isn't about me being attracted to you. That was me being a normal human being!"
"Look, I'm sorry I said that last thing, but I don't feel comfortable with you laying that close to me."
"I'm sick and tired of hearing what you are comfortably with! I'm sorry that you don't like guys, and I'm sorry that you had to give up your girl, but I'm sick of it.
Stop having nightmares then or something! What would you do if you woke up to me muttering and in some sort of mental anguish?" He didn't answer, his eyes dropping to the floor to not meet mine.
"Oh, I forgot, you would never comfort another man. How gay! And we all know that Prince Thomas is anything but that.
Well, while we're on the subject of things that make people uncomfortable. Has it ever occurred to you that this is uncomfortable for me? That maybe I don't want to feel the way I do? That I hate that I have feelings for you, and I hate that you very obviously don't have any for me?"
Tears filled my eyes, and I cursed myself for letting my emotions show so easily. Thomas was looking at me now, mouth slightly open, as if he were about to say something.
"And I hate that you won't even try! You know we are stuck with each other forever, possibly. So, what's the matter with me? Am I that unlovable? Am I that disgusting to you that even me laying by you makes you that uncomfortable?"
I hadn't meant to say all that, but it was as if something he said triggered the river of insecurities, that I'd tried so hard to overcome, to begin its course through me.
"You're not—it's not..." He struggled find the right words, my display of emotions obviously upset him, and he looked like he didn't know what to do or say anymore.
"Don't." I held up my hand, embarrassed by the whole situation, and wishing that I was anywhere but here. Crying in front Thomas. "It doesn't matter."
I tried to turn away, but he grabbed my arm. I looked up at him sharply, and I saw something in his eyes that I'd never seen before.
"Alex, I'm sorry. I've hurt you, and I don't know how to make it better. I never meant to make you feel like that. Like you weren't worthy of love. You are. I just-I can't be that person."
We were standing close now, his hand still holding onto my arm.
"Why not?" I whispered, suddenly aware of the closeness of our faces, of our eyes, our mouths. "Why not, Thomas?"
"I don't like-"
"I'm not men. I don't want you to love or be attracted to men...just me."
I brought my other hand up to touch his cheek, and for the first time, he didn't tense at the contact. His dark eyes met mine, and I could see the turmoil deep inside of them.
But he didn't back away when I leaned in closer to him, and when my lips met his, he didn't pull away.
I moved my lips against his, and felt a thrill of joy me when I felt him kiss back. It was slow and hesitant, both of us very aware of what this moment could mean.
I brought my other hand up to his chest, and his arms wrapped around me, pulling me closer towards him.
My mind was in a daze, my lips on fire. I could have melted in his arms if I hadn't had to pull away for air.
"Alex." He whispered, and the way he said my name was enough to make knees go weak. For months I'd longed for him to kiss me like this, to say my name like I was the only one he would ever care for.
I should have known it was all too good to be true.
When I looked into his eyes, I knew something was wrong. He was blinking, as if he had just woken from a daze, his body tensing against mine. And suddenly his arms were no longer about me. He took a step back, a unreadable expression on his face.
"I-I'm sorry."
And with that, he hurried out of our room, leaving me standing alone.

End of Why the Straight One? Chapter 19. Continue reading Chapter 20 or return to Why the Straight One? book page.